PDA

View Full Version : SOTW #8 Voting


♠ Fate ♠
01-31-2008, 08:24 AM
SOTW #8 Voting
The voting process is point-based. Each voter has a chance to select their 3 favourite entries, and give them points. The best tag - 3 points, the second best - 2 points, and the third best - 1 point.

Comments & critiques may be given to the tags as well, and it is encouraged. ^________^ If there is a tie, it will be considered a dual-win, unless the winners wish to battle it out in a tiebreaker.

Tom - 3 points
I love the lighting! <3
Dick - 2 points
Could use better typography, otherwise quite nice! ^^
Harry - 1 point
>: Could use a higher quality render. Needs more contrast. n.n

Voting will end on 7th February 2008, 4:25pm (GMT +8) - one week from now. Anyone may vote. Do not vote for your own entry. Please do not change your votes. Do not vote for the same person twice.

hemagoku
http://i149.photobucket.com/albums/s80/hemagoku/Untitled-1copy-10.jpg

Tsubasa
http://img215.imageshack.us/img215/5766/signaturezc2.png

HELLA PINOY
http://i22.photobucket.com/albums/b306/PINOY8706/SOTW7-3.jpg

Suzumega
http://i56.photobucket.com/albums/g161/NorthernCrown/dnsig3.jpg

spacecat
01-31-2008, 12:29 PM
Tsubasa-3 points, love the stock and the design/placement, great work.

Hella-2 nicely made all round and the text makes me laugh lol

Hemagoku-1 I like the sig but think the green is a bit too bright, if it was a diff colour or not so bright i'd love it.

Tsubasa
01-31-2008, 05:29 PM
HELLA PINOY (3 points) - Good blending and text placement. The tag is also hilarious.

Hemagoku (2 points) - The green is much to bright, perhaps a shade of brown or grey would have better suited the image. The green seems a bit out of place. Other than that, good structure and text placement.

Suzumega (1 point) - I like how you blended the three images together. Perhaps a bit more contrast would improve the sig. It seems a bit jumbled in it's current state.
L FTW

♠ Fate ♠
02-03-2008, 06:25 AM
Tsubasa (3) - Amazing concept, and great execution. <3

hemagoku (2) - You're improving. Nicely done. <3

HELLA PINOY (1) - Text could use a lot of work, but not a bad concept.

Orihime-Chan
02-03-2008, 11:17 AM
Tsubasa - 3 points
nice idea.

hemagoku - 2 points
try blending the stock with the BG..

HELLA PINOY - 1 point
another font for the text would be better!

Frosted Heart
02-03-2008, 05:09 PM
Tsubasa - 3 points (I simply adore the background and the nice use of space!)

Hella Pinoy - 2 points (Veggie for the win! ^^ Nice use of background as well and lighting)

Suzumega - 1 point (Great use of layers, but it took me a little while to make out L)

Sora Chan
02-04-2008, 08:58 PM
3 points- Pinoy because it made me laugh and I love vegita.

2 points- Suzumega. I thought it looked great!

1 point- Tsubasa cause I love the concept and it looks really nice.

♠ Fate ♠
02-08-2008, 09:13 AM
Tsubasa = 13
HELLA PINOY = 12
hemagoku = 7
Suzumega = 4